Confidential comments to executive editor

Author: mouu

August undefined, 2024

http://regulationroom.org/learn/what-effective-commenting WebComments that reference the work of your own research group in a way that would compromise the confidentiality of your review. Comments to inform the Editor of possible conflict of interest issues that you may have as a reviewer. Comments that provide essential criticisms of the manuscript should not be included here. Rather, those …

Writing a reviewer report Springer — International …

Webregarded as confidential information since the final decision regarding acceptance, revision or rejection rests with the editor Confidential evaluation Additional confidential comments to the Editor might include: • a definite recommendation regarding publication • an assessment of how much any suggested additional experiments would improve the WebApr 13, 2024 · Commercial banks across Nigeria have begun revising their interest rates following the recent changes in Monetary Policy Rate (MPR). This is coming after the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) raised it’s benchmark lending rate to 18 per cent last month in a push to contain inflation. Addressing newsmen at the bank’s Monetary Policy … brandeis university dean\u0027s list

Guidelines for reviewers - American Psychological Association

Web如题，有过审稿经验的虫友进来帮个忙，知道 Comments to the author 是写审稿意见，不明白 Confidential Comment to the Editor 该写些什么，看了说明貌似写"acceptance" 或 “rejection”就可以，虫友帮帮忙，你们都写些什么？ WebComments for only the editor: In this section, give the editor your recommendation for the manuscript and, more importantly, your reasons behind it. These usually have … WebReviewer comments to the editor: (please check all appropriate areas) Publication priority is: __ High _x_ Medium __ Low ... Confidential comments to the editor: N/A Comments to Author Dear Author, Thank you for the opportunity to review your manuscript titled, REDACTED " I offer the following recommendations for your consideration: 1. Why was ... haier air conditioner price pakistan

Reviewer Recommendation Formexampleredacted

Russia to put Ukrainian national on ‘international wanted list’ over …

WebThe following conventions should be respected: Reviewers should review the peer review policy of the Journal before revealing their reviewer role. Reviews should be conducted objectively. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate, as are defamatory/libelous remarks. Reviewers should express their views clearly with supporting arguments ... WebWriting the review: In your confidential comments to the editor, please be frank and direct in explaining why you recommend rejecting the manuscript. When writing your comments for the author, though, please keep tone in mind as you point out the paper’s flaws. Be sure to offer the authors some constructive feedback on this manuscript or for haier air conditioner motorWebThese comments will be removed from your review. Convey the same overall message in your comments to the editor and author (while the confidential message to the editor may be more direct, the overall message to both the editor and author should be the same). Confidentiality . The manuscript is a privileged document and subject to an embargo. brandeis university federal school code

"Webthose you judge merely desirable in "Remarks to the Editor" on the following page. Also, please indicate in "Remarks to the Editor" whether you prefer to review subsequent … " - Confidential comments to executive editor

Confidential comments to executive editor

WebCONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO THE EDITORS: This is an important topic and one which appears to be somewhat conflicting in the literature. This secondary, stratified analysis of … Webcomments were very helpful overall, and we are appreciative of such constructive feedback on our original submission. After addressing the issues raised, we feel the quality of the …

Did you know?

WebApr 1, 2010 · Comments to the editor are entered in a section separate from those intended for the author because the former are strictly confidential. In contrast, … WebCONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO THE EDITORS: This is an important topic and one which appears to be somewhat conflicting in the literature. This secondary, stratified analysis of an RCT is provocative and clinically relevant, and adds to similar findings from some other studies. Most of the issues I identified with the study methods

Webconfidential comments to the Editor‐in‐Chief/Associate Editor are respected, any remarks that might help to strengthen the manuscript should be directed to the authors themselves. The following is a summary of guiding principles all reviewers should be comfortable abiding by. 1. Manuscript Review WebCONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO EDITOR. Please provide the Editor with a brief confidential summary assessment considering the work’s merits, impact, and interest among AJR’s general radiologist audience. Use this space to indicate the fundamental reason underlying your reject, revise, or accept recommendation. This gestalt summary …

WebComments to authors. Your comments to authors will be read both by the authors and by the editors. They should provide a critical but constructive review, in a considerate and impartial tone. They should not reveal your confidential recommendation to reject, revise, or accept the paper, or your opinion as to whether it should be published. The ... Webmuchong.com

http://muchong.com/html/201209/4914332.html

WebNov 22, 2024 · Peer Review, Confidential Comments to the Editor, and the Golden Rule. Ann Plast Surg. 2024 Jan 1;90 (1):1-3. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000003320. Epub … haier air conditioner priceshttp://cdn.elsevier.com/promis_misc/ophtha-reviewers-guide.pdf haier air conditioner rebateWebSep 13, 2024 · The comments to the editor frequently included remarks on their own suitability as a reviewer, the journal editorial process, gratitude at being asked to review … brandeis university employment opportunitiesWebOct 2, 2024 · Get Alerts For Executive Editor Jobs. An executive editor supervises the editorial content of magazines, newspapers, or other publications. In the corporate setting, an executive editor often arranges a book's publishing. In a newspaper setting, an executive editor is the newsroom leader, and in larger newspapers, they coordinate all … brandeis university endowmentWebJul 31, 2024 · Appealing an Editor’s Decision. Perhaps the most challenging communication with an editor involves appealing the decision to reject a manuscript. Receipt of a message conveying a decision to not accept a paper is trying. It is not unusual for authors to be upset. Reviewer comments may seem unsatisfactory and the editor’s decision inexplicable. brandeis university enrollment sizeWebGuidance from our Editors. Here is some practical advice on how to conduct a good review from the point of view of our experienced Editors. Emad El-Omar, Editor-in-Chief of Gut. … haier air conditioner ratingWebConfidential Comments. You will have the possibility to introduce confidential comments for the Editorial Board’s eyes only. In these comments, you can put any information you believe is useful to assess the paper's quality, which can’t be shared with authors (e.g., because it would breach the anonymity of reviews). Conflicts of Interest haier air conditioner reddit